Milwaukee 16" x 24" Aluminum Framing Square

When you’re tackling construction projects, having a reliable framing square is essential. Recently, I had the opportunity to use Milwaukee’s 16" x 24" Aluminum Framing Square (model MLSQ024), and I must say, my experience was a blend of both highs and lows. As someone who has used various framing squares over the years, there are several aspects of this particular tool that stood out, both positively and negatively.

First impressions matter, and Milwaukee’s framing square doesn’t disappoint in this department. The bright Milwaukee red finish immediately catches your eye. Made from lightweight aluminum, it certainly has a modern, sleek look that sets it apart from the traditional steel squares. This aluminum build also means it’s resistant to rust, a significant advantage for those of us who’ve had to deal with the rusting issues of older steel squares.

The laser-etched markings are another notable feature. In my experience, these markings were easily visible, even in dim lighting conditions. This high visibility is crucial when you’re working on precise measurements. The square includes graduations for 8ths, 10ths, 12ths, and 16ths, which makes it versatile for a variety of tasks. Additionally, the scribe notches from 1" to 13" proved handy for making quick, accurate marks on lumber.

However, the tool isn't without its flaws. One of the most significant issues I encountered was the accuracy of the square itself. Despite being marketed as a premium tool, I found that it wasn’t perfectly square right out of the box. For general framing work, this might be acceptable, but for more precise woodworking tasks, this inaccuracy can become a major drawback. I tested the square using a machinist's straightedge and found a discrepancy of nearly 1/16" at the top edge. This is particularly disappointing considering the price point and the brand’s reputation.

Durability is another area where the framing square falls short. Although the aluminum construction makes it lightweight, it also makes it more susceptible to dents and damage from drops. A minor fall from my workbench left a noticeable dent, rendering the square unable to lay flat on any stock. This is something I wouldn’t expect from a tool designed for the rigors of construction work. The thicker frame does add some strength, but it’s not immune to damage from everyday accidents.

On a more positive note, the framing square’s additional features do add value. The angle-finding feature is a nice touch, allowing for quick and easy setups of common angles. The printed conversion tables are also convenient, saving time when you need quick reference for various project types. These features make the tool more versatile, especially for those who frequently switch between different types of construction and woodworking tasks.

Another aspect worth mentioning is the weight of the tool. At just over a pound, it’s noticeably lighter than traditional steel squares. This makes it easier to handle and reduces fatigue during extended use. However, the lightweight nature also contributes to its susceptibility to damage, as mentioned earlier.

One of the most frustrating aspects was dealing with the warranty. Milwaukee advertises a lifetime hand tool warranty, but when I tried to explore this option, I found it nearly impossible to find an authorized service center in my area. Additionally, hand tools are not eligible for their eService, making the warranty feel more like a marketing gimmick than a genuine offer of support. This lack of accessible warranty service is a significant downside, especially for a tool that has shown issues with accuracy and durability.

Despite these drawbacks, there are still scenarios where this framing square can be a valuable addition to your toolkit. For DIYers and hobbyists who need a reliable tool for general framing work, its ease of use and high visibility markings make it a convenient choice. The scribe notches and angle-finding features add a level of functionality that can streamline various tasks. However, for professionals or those requiring high precision, the inaccuracies and durability concerns might be deal-breakers.

In conclusion, would I recommend Milwaukee’s 16" x 24" Aluminum Framing Square? It depends on your specific needs. If you’re looking for a lightweight, easy-to-read square for general framing tasks and can overlook its potential inaccuracies, this tool might serve you well. The additional features and modern design add value and convenience for less demanding projects.

However, if precision and durability are critical for your work, you might want to consider other options. The issues with accuracy, susceptibility to damage, and the challenging warranty process make it less suitable for high-stakes, precision tasks. In that case, investing in a more robust and reliable framing square would likely be a better choice.

Ultimately, Milwaukee’s framing square offers a mix of innovation and convenience, but it falls short in areas that matter most to professionals requiring top-tier performance.