Craftsman 26-in Wide 5 Drawer Tool Chest

Craftsman has long been a name associated with quality and durability in the realm of tools and tool storage. As a long-time user of various Craftsman products, I was eager to test out the 26-in Wide 5 Drawer Tool Chest (model CMST22654BK) to see how it stacks up. This tool chest is marketed as a sturdy, USA-made tool storage solution with ample space and a secure locking mechanism. Here’s my detailed experience with it.

Initial Impressions and Build Quality

Upon unboxing the tool chest, the first thing that struck me was its weight and build. At 37 lbs, it’s relatively lightweight, which immediately raised questions about the durability of its 20-24 gauge steel construction. The metal feels thin, and there was a noticeable flex in the structure, especially around the bottom and the lid. This thinness might be a trade-off for the lower price point, but it does make the chest feel less robust than older Craftsman models.

Drawer Functionality

The tool chest features five drawers, each supported by full-extension ball-bearing slides. The drawers open smoothly and provide a satisfying glide, which is a plus. However, they do feel somewhat flimsy when loaded with tools. Each drawer can support up to 50 lbs, but I found that the drawers began to deflect side-to-side under moderate weight, which doesn't inspire a lot of confidence for long-term use.

The internal dimensions of the drawers are quite generous. The four smaller drawers measure 22 inches wide by 10.75 inches deep with 2 inches of height clearance. The bottom drawer is deeper, providing 3.5 inches of height with an additional half-inch clearance. This setup offers 3,589 cubic inches of storage, which is more than sufficient for most DIY enthusiasts and hobbyists.

Locking Mechanism

The locking system is where the tool chest shows significant room for improvement. The lock only secures the lid, which in turn is supposed to lock the drawers. However, the mechanism is somewhat finicky. If the drawers are not pushed all the way in, they might not lock properly. I found myself frequently having to adjust the drawers to ensure they were secure. This can be particularly frustrating if you’re looking for a quick and reliable lock, especially for those with children or in a shared workspace.

Usability and Practicality

Despite its drawbacks, the tool chest does have some redeeming features. The ample storage space and smooth drawer operation make it a practical choice for organizing tools. The chest’s size (26 inches wide, 17.25 inches high, and 12 inches deep) is compact enough to fit on most workbenches or under larger tool stations, making it versatile for various setups. The included set of keys is a nice touch, although the locking mechanism could be more reliable.

Durability Concerns

One of the most significant issues I encountered was the overall durability of the chest. The thin metal construction makes it prone to dents and bends, which could compromise the integrity of the tool chest over time. Additionally, the ball-bearing slides, while smooth, did not seem robust enough to handle heavy, everyday use. For professional mechanics or those who need a more heavy-duty solution, this tool chest might not hold up under the rigors of daily use.

Aesthetics

On the positive side, the tool chest does look good. The black finish is sleek and modern, and the Craftsman nameplate adds a touch of nostalgia and brand recognition. However, the nameplate itself seems to be attached rather flimsily and might not last long with regular handling.

Final Thoughts

The Craftsman 26-in Wide 5 Drawer Tool Chest is a mixed bag. It offers good storage capacity, a smooth drawer operation, and a sleek design, all at a relatively affordable price point. However, its thin metal construction, unreliable locking mechanism, and overall lack of durability make it less appealing for those who need a robust and secure tool storage solution.

If you’re a weekend DIYer or hobbyist looking for an affordable tool chest to keep your tools organized, this model might suit your needs. It’s particularly useful for stationary setups where the chest won’t be moved around frequently. However, if you require a more durable and secure storage solution for professional use or need to transport your tools regularly, I would recommend looking at more heavy-duty options.

In conclusion, while the Craftsman 26-in Wide 5 Drawer Tool Chest has its merits, it falls short in areas that are critical for long-term, heavy-duty use. For light to moderate use, it’s a decent purchase, but for more demanding needs, investing in a sturdier, more reliable tool chest would be a better choice.