Ryobi One-Way Screw Remover/Installer Set with Sleeve (3 PC.)

Removing one-way screws can be a daunting task, especially without the right tools. This was my expectation when I decided to tackle some security screws on my exterior door. I opted for the Ryobi One-Way Screw Remover/Installer Set (Model AR2016G), hoping it would simplify the process.

The set includes three tools designed to accommodate a range of screw sizes from #4 to #14 and larger. The intent is clear: to provide a solution for both installing and removing tamper-proof fasteners, which can be notoriously difficult to work with. However, my experience with this tool was a mixed bag.

Initially, I was impressed by the simplicity and the apparent robustness of the tools. The set doesn’t come with extensive instructions, which could be a setback for those unfamiliar with using specialized screw removers. However, the operation seemed straightforward enough. I decided to test the tools by hand first, as I’ve read that using a drill can sometimes deliver too much torque, making the process more challenging.

For my first attempt, I followed a cautious approach. I used the largest bit in the set and applied steady pressure while turning counter-clockwise. To my relief, the screw started to budge. It felt like a small victory, and I was hopeful. However, this success was not easily replicable. With some screws, the bit just wouldn’t catch properly, and the head would start to strip, making removal even more difficult.

To mitigate this, I switched to using an impact driver on its slowest setting, as recommended by some. The idea is that the hammering action helps set the reverse hooks of the driver into the screw head, providing better grip. This technique worked better, but it required a lot of pressure and patience. In some cases, a bit of WD-40 helped loosen the screws, making the process slightly easier.

One significant drawback is the lack of detailed instructions. For a tool that requires specific handling techniques, better guidance would have been beneficial. For instance, it’s crucial to set the bit about 1/8 inch from the end of the sleeve to ensure the sleeve covers the screw head and grabs it properly. This detail isn’t immediately obvious and can be easily overlooked without proper instructions.

Despite these challenges, I managed to remove most of the screws. However, the process was far from smooth. Some screws were too recessed or damaged, making it impossible for the bits to catch. In these cases, I had to resort to using a Dremel to cut a notch into the screw head, allowing me to use a standard flathead screwdriver for removal. This workaround isn’t ideal but sometimes necessary when dealing with particularly stubborn screws.

Interestingly, the tool also works well for installing one-way screws. If your primary need is to install these tamper-proof fasteners, this set will likely serve you well. It provides a secure and straightforward way to drive the screws in, ensuring they are tight and difficult to remove without the proper tool.

However, if your main goal is to remove one-way screws, be prepared for a bit of a struggle. The tool does work, but it requires patience, pressure, and sometimes additional tools or techniques to get the job done. It’s not a magic bullet, and it won’t solve every screw removal problem effortlessly.

In terms of build quality, the tools feel sturdy and well-made. They don’t exhibit any signs of wear after several uses, which is a plus. The bits are designed to create their own edge on the bolt, but this requires precise pressure and depth, which can be challenging to achieve consistently.

In conclusion, the Ryobi One-Way Screw Remover/Installer Set is a useful tool with certain limitations. It’s not a perfect solution for removing one-way screws, but it can make the process easier if used correctly. The lack of detailed instructions and the need for additional tools in some cases are significant drawbacks. However, for installing one-way screws, this set performs admirably.

Would I recommend this tool? It depends on your needs. If you occasionally need to deal with one-way screws and are willing to put in the effort to learn the proper techniques, this set can be a valuable addition to your toolbox. However, if you’re looking for a hassle-free, foolproof solution for removing one-way screws, you might want to consider other options or be prepared to use this tool in conjunction with other methods. The Ryobi set is not a catch-all solution, but it has its place for those willing to work with its quirks and limitations.