Craftsman Large SAE/Metric Combination Wrench Set (32 pc)

Craftsman has long been a trusted name in the tool industry, so when I got my hands on their 32-piece Large SAE/Metric Combination Wrench Set, I was eager to see how it would perform. This set, model number CMMT12080, promises a lot with its full polish chrome finish, 12-point box end for quick engagement with fasteners, and a 15° box end offset for additional knuckle clearance. But how does it hold up under real-world conditions?

First impressions matter, and right out of the box, the wrenches have a decent look. The chrome finish is bright and shiny, which gives an initial impression of quality. However, upon closer inspection, I noticed some inconsistencies in the finish. There were areas where the chrome seemed thinner and somewhat less polished. It's not a deal-breaker, but it does raise some concerns about long-term durability, especially in a rugged working environment.

The set includes a comprehensive range of sizes, both in SAE and Metric, which is a definite plus. I appreciate that it covers everything from the smaller 5mm and 1/4-inch wrenches up to the larger 22mm and 1-1/8-inch sizes. However, I was disappointed to find that some sizes like the 16mm and 13/16-inch are missing. This omission feels like a significant oversight, especially since these are common sizes in many applications. Additionally, the "miniature" wrenches included for the smaller sizes are quite thin and seem more suited for light-duty tasks. They don’t inspire confidence for more demanding jobs.

One of the standout features is the 12-point box end design, which is supposed to make it easier to engage with fasteners. In practice, this worked well. The wrenches slipped onto bolts and nuts with ease, and the 15° offset provided a bit of extra clearance for my knuckles, which is always appreciated. However, the fit on some of the wrenches felt a bit loose. They didn't grip the fasteners as snugly as I would have liked, which could lead to rounding off bolts over time.

The markings on the wrenches are large and clear, making it easy to identify the size at a glance. This might seem like a minor detail, but when you're in the middle of a project, not having to squint to read the size can save a lot of time and frustration. Unfortunately, the embossing quality varies between wrenches, with some markings being less clear and consistent than others.

Craftsman proudly touts that these wrenches meet or exceed ASME specifications, which should theoretically assure a certain level of quality and reliability. While I didn't conduct any formal testing to verify this, the build quality does feel solid overall. The steel construction gives the wrenches a good heft, and they feel balanced in hand. However, the overall machining quality leaves something to be desired. I noticed some rough edges and uneven chamfering on a few of the wrenches, which detracts from the professional feel I expect from a Craftsman product.

One of the major selling points for Craftsman tools has always been their full lifetime warranty. This set is no exception, and knowing that I can get a replacement if anything breaks is reassuring. I have had positive experiences with Craftsman's warranty service in the past, and it's good to see that this aspect of their customer service remains strong.

Despite some of the drawbacks, there are some redeeming features. The range of sizes is broad enough for most home and light automotive projects. Additionally, the price point is quite competitive, especially considering the lifetime warranty. For a hobbyist or someone just starting to build their tool collection, this set offers a lot of value.

However, for more serious mechanics or professionals, the quality concerns might be a deal-breaker. The inconsistent finish, missing sizes, and less-than-perfect fit on fasteners could lead to frustration and potential damage to workpieces. If you're used to the older, USA-made Craftsman tools, this set might feel like a step down in quality.

In conclusion, would I recommend the Craftsman 32-piece Large SAE/Metric Combination Wrench Set? It depends on your needs. For casual users or those on a budget, this set offers a decent range of sizes and the peace of mind that comes with a lifetime warranty. It's a good starter set that covers a lot of bases without breaking the bank. However, if you're a professional or someone who demands the highest quality from their tools, you might want to look elsewhere. The inconsistencies in finish and fit, along with the missing sizes, make this set less than ideal for heavy-duty or precision work. Craftsman still has a lot to offer, but this particular set falls short of the high standards many have come to expect from the brand.