Craftsman 189Pc 3Dr Mech Tool Set

Starting a new project can often be a daunting task, especially when you're not sure if you have the right tools at hand. Recently, I had the opportunity to put the Craftsman 189Pc 3Dr Mech Tool Set (model CMMT12034L) through its paces, and it turned out to be quite a comprehensive and versatile set for a variety of mechanical tasks.

Toolset Overview

The set includes 189 pieces of essential mechanics tools, featuring both SAE and Metric sizes. It comes equipped with 72-tooth ratchets, which offer a smooth operation and require less arc swing to turn fasteners, a significant convenience in tight spaces. The set also boasts a full polish chrome finish, which not only looks great but also provides corrosion resistance, extending the life of the tools.

Build Quality and Performance

Craftsman has a long-standing reputation for producing durable tools, and this set is no exception. The steel construction feels robust, and the polished finish adds a layer of confidence, ensuring that these tools will stand up to regular use in various environments. The ratchets, in particular, are a highlight. They are smooth and reliable, making them easy to use for extended periods without causing hand fatigue.

In terms of sockets and wrenches, the fit and finish are generally good, though a few pieces did have minor imperfections. Nonetheless, these issues were not deal-breakers and did not affect the overall functionality of the tools. It's worth noting that Lowe's, where I purchased the set, replaced any items with poor quality without any hassle, a testament to the customer service backing Craftsman products.

Case Design and Usability

The set comes in a rugged blow mold case designed for easy organization. However, this is where some frustrations emerged. The case features metal hinges for durability, but the plastic latches and the design of the tool slots left much to be desired. When closing the case, every tool must be snapped in perfectly, or else the case won't close properly. This can be frustrating, especially if you're in a hurry or working in less-than-ideal conditions.

Moreover, if the case is opened upside down or carried by the handle, some tools have a tendency to come loose and cause a mess. This could be a significant inconvenience, especially if you're transporting the set to different job sites. A simple redesign with better retention mechanisms could easily solve this problem, and it's something I hope Craftsman addresses in future iterations.

Additional Observations

One of the standout features of this set is the comprehensive range of tools it offers. Whether you're working on a car, a lawn tractor, or general mechanical repairs, this set likely has what you need. The inclusion of universal joints and extensions is particularly useful, making it easier to reach those awkward, hard-to-access fasteners.

Despite the case's shortcomings, the value for money is undeniable. At around $99 with free shipping, the set offers a massive array of tools at an affordable price point. Each piece, including the ratchets, extensions, and wrenches, serves a purpose, and there are no unnecessary filler items that you'll never use.

Improvements and Recommendations

While the toolset itself is impressive, there are a few areas where improvements could be made:

1. Case Design: As mentioned earlier, the case needs a redesign to ensure tools stay securely in place. Adding a mechanism that locks the tools in both the lid and the base would prevent any accidental spills.

2. Identification: It would be beneficial if the SAE and Metric tools were color-coded, similar to what some other brands offer. This would make it easier to quickly identify the right tool, especially when you're in the middle of a job.

3. Additional Adapters: Including a 1/4 inch bit adapter for screw bits would enhance the versatility of the set. This minor addition could turn the screwdriver and 1/4 inch sockets into a nut driver set, adding more functionality without significant cost.

4. Tool Variety: While the set is comprehensive, including a few additional items like pliers could make it even more versatile. Though this may be nitpicking, having a truly all-in-one set would be a significant draw for both amateurs and professionals.

Final Thoughts

Overall, the Craftsman 189Pc 3Dr Mech Tool Set is a solid choice for anyone looking to consolidate their tool collection or start from scratch. The tools themselves are of high quality, and the variety included means you'll rarely find yourself lacking the right tool for the job. However, the case design does pose some challenges, and ensuring that all tools stay in place can be a bit of a hassle.

Despite these minor drawbacks, I would still recommend this set, particularly for the value it offers. The lifetime warranty adds peace of mind, knowing that any issues with the tools themselves will be taken care of. If you're willing to deal with the occasional inconvenience of the case, this set will serve you well for a wide range of mechanical tasks.