Milwaukee Hole Saw Kit - 11PC

Milwaukee's Hole Saw Kit - 11PC is a tool that stands out in a crowded market due to its thoughtful design and robust build quality. As someone who has frequently needed to create precise holes in a variety of materials, I was keen to test this kit and see how it stacks up against other brands I've used in the past.

The first thing that struck me about this kit is its versatility. The bi-metal construction and 3.5 TPI tooth design make it suitable for both wood and metal applications, which is a significant advantage for anyone tackling a range of projects. My initial tests involved cutting through 5/8" plywood and some electrical boxes. The saws performed admirably, cutting cleanly and efficiently through both materials. However, it's worth noting that while it cuts through metal effortlessly, it does tend to catch and slow down when working with wood, especially softer types.

One of the most convenient features of this kit is the customizable storage case. Given the number of pieces in the kit, keeping everything organized can be a challenge. Milwaukee has addressed this by including a case with interchangeable pegs and reinforced grids, allowing you to configure it according to your needs. While the concept is excellent, the execution left something to be desired. The case felt flimsy, and the latch didn't close properly, which could be problematic over time. A more robust case would have been a welcome addition, especially considering the quality of the tools inside.

The quick-change mechanism for the hole saw blades is another highlight. Switching between different sizes is a breeze, making the job much more efficient. However, I did encounter a minor hiccup when trying to attach the saw to the arbor. A BB bearing fell out, and it took me a few minutes to figure out how to reassemble it correctly. Including a diagram or some instructions on this would have been helpful, especially for those new to this type of arbor design.

Performance-wise, the Hole Saw Kit excelled in most areas. The teeth are sharp and durable, and the saws cut smoothly through both wood and metal. I particularly appreciated the slots for easy plug removal, which saved me a lot of time and frustration. The saws also feature a special coating designed for faster cutting, and I found this to be effective in reducing resistance and heat build-up.

However, the kit isn't without its drawbacks. One significant issue is the length of the included drill bits. They are somewhat short, which can make it challenging to start a cut accurately, especially if you're not working at a perfect 90-degree angle. This can cause the blade to catch and "walk," marring the material. Using a drill press can mitigate this issue, but it's something to be aware of if you plan to use a hand drill.

Durability is always a concern with tools that see heavy use, and while the saws themselves are built to last, the same can't be said for the arbor. I experienced some issues with the locking nut for the Allen key, which sprang off after a few uses. This essentially rendered the arbor unusable until I could replace it, which was disappointing.

Despite these issues, there are many positives to highlight. The saws cut cleanly, and the teeth stay sharp even after repeated use. I used the 3" bit extensively on OSB and plywood, making over 300 cuts, and it continued to perform well. The hole saws are also backed by a lifetime warranty on tooth breakage, which provides some peace of mind.

Price is always a consideration, and this kit offers good value, especially if you can snag it on sale. The range of sizes included covers most common needs, and the ability to use the saws on multiple materials adds to their versatility. However, the quality of the storage case and some of the components like the arbor could be improved to make this an even better investment.

In conclusion, Milwaukee's Hole Saw Kit - 11PC is a solid choice for both DIY enthusiasts and professionals. It excels in cutting through various materials, offers convenient features like quick-change blades and easy plug removal, and comes with a versatile, though somewhat flimsy, storage case. While there are some areas for improvement, particularly with the case and the arbor, the overall performance and durability of the saws make this kit a worthwhile addition to any toolbox.

Would I recommend this tool? Yes, but with some reservations. If you're looking for a versatile and durable hole saw kit and can overlook the shortcomings of the storage case and arbor, this kit is a great option. Its ability to handle different materials and the convenience of the quick-change mechanism make it a valuable tool for a wide range of applications. However, if you prioritize case quality and long-term reliability of all components, you might want to consider other options or be prepared to make some additional purchases to address these issues.