Craftsman 1/2-in Drive TORX Bit Impact Socket Set

Craftsman's 1/2-in Drive TORX Bit Impact Socket Set, model number CMMT50839, is designed to tackle those stubborn TORX fasteners with the promise of durability and ease of use. As someone who frequently works on vehicles and various DIY projects, I was eager to see if this set lived up to the Craftsman name, which has long been synonymous with quality tools.

First Impressions and Build Quality

Right out of the box, the set's black oxide finish catches the eye. This finish is intended to provide corrosion resistance, a crucial feature for tools that are likely to be exposed to harsh environments. The large markings on each socket make it easy to identify the sizes, which range from T40 to T70. This convenience can't be overstated, especially when you're in the middle of a project and need to quickly grab the right size.

The sockets themselves feel solid and have a good heft, suggesting they are made from high-quality steel. The set includes seven pieces, all designed to fit a 1/2-inch drive, which is standard for many impact wrenches and ratchets. The full lifetime warranty is a reassuring touch, indicating that Craftsman stands behind their product.

Performance on the Job

I first put the set to the test on a truck project that involved removing some rusted bed bolts. The T55 socket was up to the task, handling the high torque demands without any signs of wear or damage. This was an encouraging start, as rusted bolts often present a significant challenge. The socket's performance here suggested that the set could indeed handle heavy-duty tasks, at least initially.

However, my experience took a turn when I moved on to a different part of the project. Using the T47 socket on a seatbelt bolt, I encountered a significant issue: the socket snapped almost immediately under pressure. This was disappointing, especially given the positive experience with the T55. It was clear that not all sockets in the set shared the same level of durability.

Further Testing and Observations

Undeterred, I continued testing the other sockets in various applications. The T60 socket was used to change a serpentine belt and unload the belt tensioner, tasks that require considerable torque. This socket performed admirably, showing no signs of twisting or distortion. It was a reminder that when the sockets work, they work well.

Yet, the inconsistency in performance was hard to ignore. The T45 socket shattered on first use while removing rusty bolts, even when used with a ratchet instead of an impact gun. This was a major letdown and raised questions about the overall reliability of the set.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Corrosion Resistance: The black oxide finish does a good job of protecting the sockets from rust, which is crucial for longevity.
• Easy Identification: The large markings are a simple but effective feature, making it easy to find the right size quickly.
• Lifetime Warranty: Craftsman's commitment to replacing defective tools is a significant advantage, although the replacement process can be slow.

Cons:

• Inconsistent Durability: The biggest drawback is the inconsistent performance of the sockets. Some hold up well under high torque, while others break too easily.
• Not Truly Impact-Ready: Despite being marketed as impact sockets, several pieces in the set failed under impact use, which is a critical flaw for a tool designed for heavy-duty applications.
• Slow Replacement Process: While the lifetime warranty is a plus, the time it takes to get a replacement can be frustrating, especially when you're in the middle of a project.

Final Thoughts

Craftsman's 1/2-in Drive TORX Bit Impact Socket Set offers a mixed bag of performance. There are moments where the set shines, handling tough jobs with ease and demonstrating the durability one expects from Craftsman tools. However, these moments are overshadowed by instances where the sockets fail under pressure, raising concerns about the overall reliability of the set.

Would I recommend this tool? It depends on your needs. If you're looking for a set to handle occasional light to moderate tasks, this set might suffice, especially given the convenience of the large markings and the corrosion-resistant finish. However, for heavy-duty applications or professional use, the inconsistency in performance and the risk of sockets breaking under impact make it hard to fully endorse this set.

In summary, while Craftsman's TORX Bit Impact Socket Set has some commendable features, the inconsistent durability and performance issues make it a less than ideal choice for demanding tasks. For those in need of a reliable, heavy-duty socket set, it might be worth exploring other options that offer more consistent performance.