TOPGREENER Kalide Combo Dimmer Switch with 3-Speed Fan Control for Dimmable 200W LED/CFL Lights and Fan Combination Switch, Single Pole, Neutral Wire Not Required, TGDSFS3-W, White

Why I reached for a combo switch

In a couple of bedrooms, I wanted independent control over a ceiling fan and its light without adding extra boxes or relying on handheld remotes. The Kalide combo switch promised exactly that: a single, wall-mounted control with a three-speed fan slider and a separate full-range light dimmer. After installing two units and living with them for several weeks, I’ve formed a clear view of where this switch excels—and where you’ll want to tread carefully.

Design and build quality

The Kalide combo switch feels sturdier than most plastic dual controls I’ve used. The sliders travel smoothly with a definitive detent on the fan side and a satisfying click when you push the light slider into the OFF position. There are no exposed slots along the slider tracks, which gives the face a clean, modern look and should help keep dust out over time.

The face is polycarbonate thermoplastic with a UL94 V-2 flammability rating and good heat/fade resistance. In practice, that translates to a finish that doesn’t scuff easily and resists discoloration near heat sources. The icons for “fan” and “light” are subtly embossed; they look tidy but they’re low-contrast, so if you prefer highly legible labels you might wish they stood out more.

It’s UL listed and backed by a 1‑year warranty. A wall plate is not included, so plan to buy one. Make sure you get a compatible plate; the opening and profile matter for a clean fit.

What it’s compatible with (and what it’s not)

This is the critical section. The Kalide combo switch is purpose-built for a very specific setup:

• A 3-speed mechanical ceiling fan that uses a pull chain to change speeds (not a variable-speed or DC motor fan, and not a fan with a built-in remote or smart module).
• A separate light circuit on the same fan or a separate light fixture fed by its own switched leg.
• Dimmable bulbs only if you’re using LED/CFL. The dimmer supports up to 200 W of LED/CFL or 360 W of incandescent/halogen.
• Fan motor load up to 2.5 A.
• Single-pole control only—this is not a 3-way switch.

Critically, your switch box must already have two switched conductors running to the fan/light location (commonly a 14/3 or 12/3 cable). The Kalide needs two loads: one for the fan, one for the light. If you only have a single switched leg feeding both, this is not going to give you independent control without re-running cable.

It’s also not compatible with smart lighting fixtures or fans with integrated electronic controls. If your fan came with a remote or Wi‑Fi hub, you’ll want to remove or bypass that module, or choose a control designed for that system.

Installation experience

Assuming your wiring is ready, installation is straightforward. No neutral is required, which is a plus in older homes. You’ll connect line/hot in, separate load leads for fan and light, and ground. The body isn’t unusually deep, but once you tuck the wire nuts and additional conductors for a dual-load circuit, space can get tight in shallow metal boxes. I needed to tidy up the conductors and use compact connectors to keep everything neat.

Two practical tips:
- Set the fan’s pull chain to high and leave it there. After that, use the wall control exclusively to avoid confusing the capacitor network inside the fan.
- Before closing up the box, run through all three fan speeds and dimming range to make sure your leads aren’t reversed and the sliders behave as expected.

Plan to pick up a matching wall plate. The clean look depends on a plate that sits flush with the slider openings.

Day-to-day performance

• Fan control: The three fan positions are distinct and repeatable. On a 52-inch, 3-speed AC fan, low is a true low, medium is useful for nighttime, and high is appropriately brisk. On a different, budget fan with a slightly different capacitor pack, high felt a notch shy of the motor’s native top speed; medium and low were both usable but a hair conservative. This is normal with some fans—the switch works through a capacitor network, and those values don’t always align perfectly with every motor. If you find the top speed underwhelming on high, try setting the fan’s pull chain to high again to confirm it’s not mid-chain.

• Light dimming: With quality dimmable LEDs, I got smooth, flicker-free dimming from about 100% down to roughly 25–30% before cutoff. The exact floor depends on the bulbs and drivers. With one can-light retrofit kit, the minimum sat closer to 45–50%, which made the low end brighter than ideal at night. Swapping to a different brand moved the floor down significantly. That variability isn’t unique to this switch—it’s the reality of pairing TRIAC-style dimmers with mixed LED drivers. If your minimum brightness is too high, change bulbs before you blame the control.

The OFF click on the light slider is audible but not loud; I like the certainty it provides, and it helps avoid ghosting on sensitive LED loads.

Noise, heat, and electrical behavior

Neither unit produced buzzing from the dimmer when paired with decent dimmable LEDs. On the fan side, one of my fans was whisper quiet at all settings; the other introduced a faint hum on high that disappeared at medium. That usually indicates the motor and the control’s capacitor steps aren’t a perfect match. It’s not dangerous, but if it bothers you, try a different control or keep that fan at medium.

The face of the unit stayed cool during extended use. No odor, no discoloration.

Aesthetics and ergonomics

For a crowded multi-gang box, the Kalide cleans up the wall nicely by combining two functions into a single yoke. The sliders are easy to identify by feel after a day or two; the tactile detents on the fan side are especially helpful in the dark. Because the design has no exposed slider slot, it wipes clean with a cloth—handy in kitchens or kids’ rooms.

I do wish the tiny fan/light icons had a touch more contrast. It’s a minor quibble, and the minimalist look is otherwise excellent.

Limitations and gotchas

• You must have two separate load wires in the wall to split fan and light. No workaround in the switch can change that.
• Not for fans with integrated remotes, variable-speed DC motors, or smart modules, and not for smart fixtures. Mixing them leads to odd behavior or damage.
• Some LED loads won’t dim as low as you’d like, regardless of the control. Choose high-quality dimmable LEDs and be ready to test a bulb or two to find your preferred minimum.
• The fan load is capped at 2.5 A. That’s fine for most residential ceiling fans, but check the nameplate.
• Wall plate is extra. Make sure the plate you buy is explicitly compatible so you don’t end up with gaps or binding sliders.

Who it’s for

• Homeowners with a 3-speed pull-chain fan and separate light lead who want consolidated, on-wall control without remotes or smart ecosystems.
• Renovations where no neutral is available at the switch box.
• Anyone looking to replace a basic rheostat or clunky dual toggle with a neater, slider-based solution.

If you have a single switched leg to a fan/light combo, prefer smart controls, or have a DC/remote fan, this isn’t your switch.

The bottom line

The Kalide combo switch does what it sets out to do: it gives you reliable, tactile control over a standard 3-speed fan and a dimmable light from one clean-looking device. It’s well-built for the price, UL listed, and requires no neutral. In daily use, the fan speeds are consistent, the dimmer is smooth with the right bulbs, and the ergonomics are thoughtfully executed. Its success depends on proper compatibility—specifically, a 3-speed AC fan with a separate light leg and quality dimmable bulbs. If you can check those boxes, you’ll likely be pleased.

Recommendation: I recommend the Kalide combo switch for conventional 3-speed, pull-chain fans with separate light wiring. It’s a solid, budget-friendly upgrade that tidies up the wall and works predictably, provided you match it with the right fan type and dimmable LEDs. If your setup involves a smart/remote fan, a single switched leg, or you demand ultra-low LED dim levels with any bulb, look elsewhere. Otherwise, this is an easy win.